Strategy report · Updated Jul 31, 2026
What's working for @pluslettering on Instagram.
Plus Lettering | Personalized Designs
20.1K followers · 319 posts
“⚡ Create beautiful lettering faster 🏷️ Curved names & custom projects 🚀 For Cricut users & crafters ⬇️ Claim your maker shortcut 👇”
Engagement rate
0.03%
Per post, last 90 days
Posts per week
2.3
Niche avg 4.0
Average likes
4
2 avg comments
Post mix
Last 90 days · 319 posts indexed
01
Top-performing posts
The three posts pulling the most engagement in the last 90 days.
reel 0.15% engagedEfficiency is the key to scaling your handmade business. When you can generate high-quality, consistent designs in seconds, you transform how you handle your workload and take the stress out of custom requests. #customorders #smallbizowner #craftinglife #personalizedgifts #productionhacks
reel 0.15% engagedThe layout does the work, the strategy handles the rest. This automation workflow ensures clean results every single time without starting from scratch. #customgifts #acrylicsign #craftbusiness #cricutmaker #handmadeproducts smallbusinesstips diycrafts packagingideas personalizedgifts makersgonnamake
reel 0.10% engagedStop spending hours manually adjusting nodes for your custom signs. When your lettering workflow is natively optimized for your machine, you achieve professional, clean edges every time without the trial and error. Elevate the quality of your custom inventory by switching to a design system that handles the precision for you. Access the vector shortcut on my profile ⭐ #customgifts #craftbusiness #cricutmaker #vinylcrafts #handmadeproducts
02
Content pillars
AI-clustered themes the account posts about, with example posts pulled live from Instagram.
03
Posting rhythm
Cadence and timing patterns over the last 12 weeks.
2.3 posts/week
Niche benchmark · 4.0/week
Best days
Thursday · Friday · Wednesday
Best hours
7-9am · 12-2pm
04
Signature hooks
Caption patterns the account reuses across high-performing posts.
Drop [keyword] and I'll send you [offer] via DM.
Used 14×
Drop Shortcut and I'll send you the Lettering Generator + Free 300 Cut Files via DM.
Drop Shortcut and I'll send you the Lettering Generator + Free 300 Commercial Cut Files Pack via DM.
Drop Shortcut and I'll send you the Lettering Generator plus the Free 300+ Commercial Cut Files Pack directly via DM.
Type [keyword] and I'll send you [offer] straight to your DMs.
Used 6×
Type Shortcut and I'll send you the shortcut I use, plus access to the Free 300+ Commercial Cut Files Pack.
Type SHORTCUT and I'll send you the workflow link + access pass for 300 free SVGs straight to your DMs!
Type Shortcut and I'll send you the workflow link + access pass for 300 free SVGs straight to your DMs!
Stop [painful task] if you want [better outcome].
Used 2×
Stop spending hours manually adjusting nodes for your custom signs.
[X] can look [positive] until [the painful reality].
Used 4×
Branded notebooks & personalized stationery can look intimidating until you see how clean the final result can be.
Personalized mugs & custom drinkware ideas can be exciting until the design part becomes the hardest step.
Script lettering can look amazing on custom products, but preparing those designs for vinyl projects can become frustrating.
Via @[partner] — this is the workflow I help makers simplify.
Used 3×
Via @timoostrich — this is the workflow I help makers simplify. Comment Shortcut and I'll send it via DM.
Via @timoostrich — this is the workflow I help makers simplify. Comment Shortcut and I'll send it via DM.
Via @timoostrich — this is the workflow I help makers simplify.
Unlock signature hooks
Continue to Postana to put this strategy to work with a paid content plan.
Build my content plan with Postana05
Strategy summary
What's working, what to fix, and what to ship next.
TL;DR
This account has one strong mechanical idea, a keyword-triggered DM funnel, but it is running that idea into the ground with near-zero content variation. The top-performing posts (indices 4, 5, 13) averaged 19 likes, while the 15 posts published in the final week of July averaged under 2 likes each. That collapse is not an algorithm problem. It is a content fatigue problem caused by posting slight rewrites of the same script across 2.3 posts per week when the posts are not differentiated enough to justify the volume.
The DM-trigger hook appears in every single post, which trains followers to ignore the CTA because it is always there. The account has no educational payoff posts, no results proof, and no community content beyond three @timoostrich reposts. The highest-engagement posts lean on outcome framing and specific craft niches (signs, stationery, custom gifts) rather than generic workflow promises. That contrast is the clearest signal in the data.
The fix is not posting more. It is making 3 to 4 posts per week feel distinct. Rotate across a proof post, a tutorial moment, a product-specific demo, and one DM-trigger post. Reserve the keyword CTA for one post per rotation so it retains scarcity. The free cut files offer is a real hook. It just needs a post that earns it.
Working
3- Outcome-specific reels tied to a product category (signs, stationery, drinkware) consistently earn higher engagement than generic workflow posts.
- The free 300 cut files offer is a tangible lead magnet that gives the DM CTA real pull when used selectively.
- The contrast hook structure (looks good until the painful reality) in posts 15, 18, and 27 sets up the solution naturally.
Risks
4- The DM trigger CTA appears in every post, removing any scarcity and training followers to scroll past it.
- Zero posts show a real result, a before-and-after, or a customer outcome, so there is no social proof anchoring the promise.
- Posting 15 near-identical reels in one week caused a severe engagement drop and likely hurt distribution with the algorithm.
- Captions are long but repetitive, covering the same pain and the same offer with different word order each time.
Ship next
5- Cut posting volume to 3 to 4 per week and assign each post a distinct role: proof, tutorial, product demo, or CTA.
- Reserve the keyword DM trigger for one post per week maximum so it reads as a genuine offer, not a template.
- Film one before-and-after result post showing a real maker project improved by the workflow, then pin it to the profile.
- Build a content calendar with 4 rotating pillar slots so no two consecutive posts share the same structure or hook.
- Test posting Thursday and Friday between 7 and 9am, where the late-June higher-engagement posts cluster by date.
Unlock the full strategy
Continue to Postana to put this strategy to work with a paid content plan.
Build my content plan with Postana